Some of cinema’s most famous characters were first offered to someone else. Here are stars who turned down iconic roles, who stepped in and what the actors later said, as compiled by Hello Magazine from their interviews.
Stars who turned down iconic roles
Will Smith: Neo in The Matrix
Role went to Keanu Reeves. Smith chose Wild Wild West. He later told The Hollywood Reporter: “Keanu was perfect. Laurence Fishburne was perfect.”
John Travolta: Forrest Gump
Role went to Tom Hanks. Travolta made Pulp Fiction instead, and the two went head to head for Best Actor, which Hanks won.
Tom Selleck: Indiana Jones
Role went to Harrison Ford. CBS would not release him from Magnum, P.I. He told TODAY that Magnum “was the best thing that ever happened to me.”
Michelle Pfeiffer: The Silence of the Lambs
Role went to Jodie Foster. She told The New Yorker: “It was that evil won in the end… I didn’t want to put that out into the world.”
Molly Ringwald: Pretty Woman
Role went to Julia Roberts. She told The Guardian: “Julia Roberts was wonderful in it, but I didn’t really like the story.”
Hugh Jackman: James Bond
Role went to Daniel Craig. Jackman told IndieWire he worried about having no time for anything beyond Bond and Wolverine.
Claire Danes: Titanic
Role went to Kate Winslet. Danes said on Armchair Expert she had “zero regret.”
Matt Damon: Avatar
Role went to Sam Worthington. Damon was committed to finishing a Bourne film. Hello Magazine says the role would have meant a $250 million payout. “I’m sure it’s the most money an actor ever turned down,” he said.
Rachel McAdams: The Devil Wears Prada
Role went to Anne Hathaway. Director David Frankel told EW the studio offered it to her three times.
Emily Blunt: Black Widow
Role went to Scarlett Johansson. Blunt told Howard Stern she was contracted to Gulliver’s Travels and called it “a bit of a heartbreaker.”
At a glance
| Star | Role passed on | Went to |
|---|---|---|
| Will Smith | Neo in The Matrix | Keanu Reeves |
| John Travolta | Forrest Gump | Tom Hanks |
| Tom Selleck | Indiana Jones | Harrison Ford |
| Michelle Pfeiffer | The Silence of the Lambs | Jodie Foster |
| Molly Ringwald | Pretty Woman | Julia Roberts |
| Hugh Jackman | James Bond | Daniel Craig |
| Claire Danes | Titanic | Kate Winslet |
| Matt Damon | Avatar | Sam Worthington |
| Rachel McAdams | The Devil Wears Prada | Anne Hathaway |
| Emily Blunt | Black Widow | Scarlett Johansson |
Why stars say no
The reasons repeat: contracts with other projects, as with Selleck, Damon and Blunt; discomfort with the material, as with Pfeiffer and Ringwald; or simply timing, as Danes described. Few say they regret it, and Smith argued that the film would have been worse with him in it.
Sometimes the right actor ends up in the right part. See Jennifer Lawrence’s return to Katniss and our list of Hollywood rags to riches stars.
FAQ
Who turned down the role of Neo in The Matrix?
Will Smith, who chose Wild Wild West. The role went to Keanu Reeves.
Why did Matt Damon turn down Avatar?
He was committed to finishing a Bourne film and did not want to leave it early.
Who was offered Forrest Gump before Tom Hanks?
John Travolta, who made Pulp Fiction instead.
Sources
- Hello Magazine
